Looking For No Credit Check Auto Insurance? Explore The Best Options And Drive Car
Agreed Value Car Insurance
Reviewed by the AtozInsuranceusa editorial team.
Agreed value car insurance uses a car value that you and the insurer accept before a loss. For a covered total loss, that sum is the starting point for what the plan pays. Your deductible is your share of a covered claim. That and the terms of the plan still apply. The insurer does not cut that value for age and wear at the time of the loss.
This can help when a used car price guide does not show what a classic car or rare model is worth. It can also help if you have spent years bringing a car back to life. You still need to choose the right coverage for your risks. Agreed value tells you how the plan values the car. It does not mean the plan pays for each type of loss.
Cost depends on the car, drivers, location and terms. Get quotes that use the same value and coverage.
Before you compare quotes, check three points:
- Does the written plan use agreed value rather than stated value?
- Does the plan allow how, where and how often you drive?
- What must you pay toward a claim, and what does the plan leave out?
Do not choose a quote on price alone. A low price has little use if the plan bars your daily commute or does not cover key changes to your car. A sum shown on a quote also does not prove that it offers agreed value.
AtozInsuranceusa is a quote comparison service. Use it to compare car insurance quote options. The insurer decides if it will accept the car and value. It also sets the terms and start date. Ask the quote provider if it can offer agreed value for your car and state.
Agreed value vs. stated value vs. actual cash value
Agreed value sets the car’s value for the plan before a loss. Actual cash value, or ACV, is what the car was worth just before the loss. Stated value often sets a cap. The plan may pay the lower of the stated sum or ACV. Check the claim payout clause to see which method the quote uses.
Value method | How it works for a covered total loss | What to check |
Agreed value | Uses the value approved before the loss | The written agreement and allowed deductions |
Stated value | Often pays the lesser of the stated amount or ACV | Whether the policy can settle at ACV |
Actual cash value | Uses the car’s value just before the loss | How age, wear and condition affect that value |
Hagerty’s guide to agreed and guaranteed value explains these differences. Names on sales pages can vary. Read the plan’s terms. Do not treat a stated sum as an agreed payout.
A simple total loss example
Assume a restored car has an agreed value of $60,000 and a $1,000 deductible. A covered total loss could result in $59,000 before any other changes that apply.
Now assume the same car has an ACV of $45,000 when the loss occurs. An ACV claim with that deductible could pay $44,000. A stated value plan with a $60,000 cap could also pay $44,000 if its terms require the lower value.
These examples are not quotes or promises to pay. They assume the loss is covered and you do not keep the salvage. They leave out taxes, fees and other changes to the sum paid. The point is to check how the plan pays for a total loss before you compare prices.
Who should compare agreed value car insurance?
Start with agreed value options if your car’s worth depends on rarity, condition or work that a standard quote may miss. Cars worth asking about include restored classics, antique cars, cars made in small numbers and newer collector cars.
A car’s age alone does not settle the question. Two cars from the same year can be worth quite different sums. One may need major work. The other may have rare parts from the factory and proof of the work done to restore it.
For a custom car, list each major change when you ask for a quote. Include the engine, body, paint, brakes, wheels and interior. Hagerty’s modified vehicle program, for example, considers several types of hot rods, custom cars and replicas. Other plans may use different rules.
A plan may suit your car’s value but limit how you use it or where you keep it. If you drive a car each day and can show its worth with used car sales, compare an ACV plan too. Choose the terms that fit the car and your use.
Can you insure a daily driver at agreed value?
Some plans allow it. Grundy’s Motor Vehicle Program offers agreed value for daily drivers as well as collector and exotic cars. Many classic car plans have stricter use rules. Hagerty says cars on its collector plan cannot serve as daily drivers.
Tell the quote provider if you drive to work, school or errands. Explain whether the car is your only vehicle. Do not describe daily use as rare trips for fun to fit a quote. Ask which plan fits your use and whether all household drivers need another car.
Must the car stay in a locked garage?
Storage rules vary. Hagerty prefers enclosed, secure storage but also considers carports, driveways and parking garages. Its vehicle eligibility page lists its rules for storage, drivers and cars used each day.
Give the full address where you keep the car. Describe the space. If the car stays at more than one place, tell the provider. Also ask about overnight trips, car shows and hotel parking. Check travel rules as well as home storage rules.
How do you choose and document the car's value?
Choose a value you can back up with proof of the car’s condition and worth. The price you paid may not show the worth of new work or changes in demand. Ask what proof the insurer needs before you pay an expert to assess the value.
Progressive’s agreed value insurance guide says insurers may use photos, appraisals, vehicle history and condition to assess value. It also says almost all collector cars placed through its Hagerty program do not need an appraisal. That does not set the rules for all insurers.
Prepare a small file with:
- The vehicle identification number, year, make, model and trim.
- Clear photos of the exterior, interior, engine and any rare features.
- Records of major repairs, restoration work and custom parts.
- The title, purchase records and relevant vehicle history.
- Recent sales of cars with similar features and condition.
- An appraisal if the insurer requests one.
A bill for $12,000 of work does not, by itself, prove that the car is worth $12,000 more. Ask how the insurer weighs that work.
For example, do not compare a car you have fully restored only with project cars listed for sale. Match the trim, engine, state of repair and key features as closely as you can. An asking price also differs from the price a buyer has paid. Explain any gaps in your proof rather than filling them with a guess.
Keep the approval. Check that the listed car and agreed sum match your request.
What coverage should you compare with agreed value?
Compare coverage for damage to your car, harm to others and any extras you need. Setting an agreed value does not take the place of those choices.
Collision coverage helps pay for crash damage. Comprehensive coverage helps pay for theft, fire, flood and other covered losses besides a crash. Liability coverage helps pay for harm you cause to other people and their property. The Texas Department of Insurance auto guide explains these types of coverage. What you must buy and the required limits vary by state.
Theft deserves a place in the discussion even if you drive few miles. The National Insurance Crime Bureau reported 659,880 vehicle thefts nationwide in 2025. Its March 2026 report counts all reported vehicle thefts, not just collector cars. It does not measure your car’s chance of theft.
Ask how the agreed value applies to both a crash total loss and an unrecovered theft. Also check terms for glass, spare parts, towing, shipping and rental cars. If you need a flatbed tow or own rare spare parts, ask about those needs by name.
Get written answers about racing, track events, paid use and mechanical breakdowns. Those uses and risks may be excluded.
How do partial repair claims work?
If the car can be fixed, the claim does not pay the whole agreed value. The insurer checks the covered damage and the cost to fix it. What it pays depends on the work it agrees to, your deductible and the plan’s terms. Hagerty’s claims FAQ explains how its repair claims work.
Compare repair terms before you buy. Ask whether the plan pays for parts from the car maker, other parts that fit or parts made to order. Ask how it handles custom paint, work by a skilled shop and parts that are hard to find.
If you have a shop you trust to restore the car, ask about shop choice and how costs get approved. Discuss what happens if the shop finds hidden damage after work begins. Check with the insurer before you agree to costs that go past the sum it approved.
How much does agreed value car insurance cost?
You need a quote for your car, drivers, home address and use. An average price can hide large gaps between a classic car used on weekends and an exotic driven each day. Do not treat a sample classic car rate as the cost to insure any car at agreed value.
The price can depend on the car, where you keep it, your past claims and how you drive. The coverage you choose also affects cost. The Texas Department of Insurance explains these cost factors in its auto guide. Collector plans add their own rules to check.
When quotes differ, ask why. Does one quote list a lower car value? Does it have a larger deductible? Does it bar the drive to work you told the agent about? Do the plans last the same length of time?
Use this list to keep the comparison fair:
Quote detail | What to match or confirm |
Insured value | The same requested amount and an agreed value settlement clause |
Car damage coverage | Both the covered causes and exclusions |
Deductibles | Separate amounts for collision and comprehensive coverage |
Driving rules | Your mileage, errands, commute and trips |
Other limits | Liability limits and any required state coverage |
Repair and extras | Parts, towing, spare parts and rental benefits |
Total price | The policy term, fees and cost of installment payments |
Our guide to classic car insurance costs can help you plan cost questions. Use your quote and the written terms to make your choice.
How can you get an agreed value quote?
Start with your ZIP code, car details, value you want and how you drive. Then ask if the provider can quote the right plan. Use these steps to review an offer:
- Describe the car. State its condition, major changes and any work still in progress.
- Explain its use. Include annual miles, commuting, trips, storage and household drivers.
- Submit value records. Send the photos and documents the insurer asks for.
- Match the quotes. Use the same value, coverage and deductibles where you can.
- Review the offer. Ask for the claim payout terms, use rules and any endorsements you need. An endorsement changes the plan’s terms.
- Confirm the start. Get the agreed value, start date and time, what you must pay and proof of coverage.
Do not assume that sending a form starts insurance. Ask if more checks or records are needed. If you need coverage before you pick up a car you bought, tell the provider your pickup date. Check that the plan covers the trip before it ships or you drive it home.
Keep your old plan in place until the new one starts. That helps avoid a gap while the insurer checks your request. The Texas Department of Insurance shopping guide advises shoppers to avoid gaps and check licenses. Ask your own state’s insurance department how to check a company’s license and complaint record.
When should you update the agreed value?
Check the value when you renew, after major work or when the market shifts. Hagerty recommends revisiting the amount as collector values change. A value that made sense years ago may no longer match the car you own now.
Keep a record of new parts, work and photos. Send it to the insurer and ask if it needs to agree to a new value. Do not assume that money spent on the car raises the plan’s limit on its own.
For work in progress, ask how the plan treats a car you have taken apart. Ask about parts stored off the car too. Ask about the shop’s address and trips between shops. Some programs offer coverage designed for cars under construction. Hagerty lists such an option on its modified vehicle page. Check its limits and where you can buy it. Do not assume the base plan includes it.
What happens after a covered total loss?
Report the loss and follow the insurer’s claim instructions. Keep photos, receipts and your policy records. Ask the adjuster for a written breakdown showing the agreed amount, deductible and each other adjustment. The insurer must still check whether the loss is covered.
Use our guide on what to say to an insurance adjuster to prepare for that discussion. State the facts you know. Make clear what you cannot confirm.
If you want to keep the damaged car, ask about salvage before accepting the settlement. Hagerty’s coverage guide explains that keeping salvage can cut the payout. Its modified vehicle page lists a separate Cherished Salvage option with its own terms. Ask whether your own quote has a similar feature and what rules apply.
Read the practical steps for buying back a totaled car if you want to rebuild. Check state title and registration rules before planning to drive it again. Also ask how taxes and fees appear in the settlement; that can depend on your state and plan.
Frequently asked questions
Not always. The agreed value and what you owe are two distinct sums. You may still owe money after a claim. GAP coverage can help with some loan shortfalls. Its own terms apply. The Texas Department of Insurance GAP guide explains its purpose and exclusions. Check your lender's requirements and the coverage needed for a financed car before switching plans.
No. Agreed value uses the approved dollar value. New car replacement is a distinct benefit. It has its own rules for which cars qualify and what it pays. Ask for the written benefit details if a provider uses both phrases. Do not assume either option includes the other.
A later request does not rewrite the plan in force when the loss took place. Report increases in value before a loss and get the insurer to agree to each change. If you find an error in your records, ask the insurer how it will review that error.
Compare the value, price and driving rules together
Keep your proof of value ready. Ask clear questions about total losses, repairs and driving limits. Review the written terms before you choose.
AtozInsuranceusa helps you compare insurance quotes. Start with your ZIP code and car details, then ask the quoting provider for an agreed value option that fits your car. Compare the agreed sum and what the plan covers alongside the price. Use those details to make your choice.
References and Sources
- Progressive: Agreed value insurance and stated value differences
- Hagerty: Agreed and guaranteed value insurance
- Hagerty: Vehicle eligibility and driving restrictions
- Grundy: Motor Vehicle Program for collector cars and daily drivers
- Texas Department of Insurance: Auto insurance coverage and shopping guide